return

Celebratio Mathematica

Barry C. Mazur

Barry Mazur: Beginnings

by Rob Kirby

Barry Charles Mazur was born in New York on 19 Decem­ber 1937. His fath­er was an Amer­ic­an-born print­er, whose par­ents came from Po­land. Barry’s moth­er, Louise Biegeleis­en, was born in Warsaw and came to the US in her teens. When Barry’s fath­er served for four years as an in­fan­try­man in World War II, Barry’s ma­ter­nal grand­moth­er — an Or­tho­dox Jew — helped raise (and in­flu­ence) him, guided by his great uncles who lived in Bor­ough Park, Brook­lyn.

From the age of four to twelve and a half, Barry went to the ye­shiva named after Rabbi Is­rael Salanter. He re­ceived an in­tense edu­ca­tion where the philo­sophy was “we are all little mice nib­bling at the in­fin­ite cheese of know­ledge.” One’s spir­itu­al duty is to try to un­der­stand. War orphans would turn up at the ye­shiva, but the war and the hor­rors of what was hap­pen­ing in Europe were hardly ever men­tioned.

Barry had a slightly older friend who told him about ham ra­dio, the con­struc­tion of an­ten­nas, and (puzz­ling to Barry) the prop­er­ties of stand­ing waves. This sparked an in­terest in un­der­stand­ing elec­tron­ics from a philo­soph­ic­al or the­or­et­ic­al point of view. He gradu­ated from the ye­shiva in 1950. Against the will of the more or­tho­dox side of his fam­ily — but with the sup­port of his par­ents — he left re­li­gious school­ing and went to the Bronx High School of Sci­ence. Bronx Sci­ence was not as in­tense as the ye­shiva, so there was time to take up box­ing three days a week, and there were girls! Amidst all this, his in­terest in math in­creased.

In 1954, Barry went to MIT. War­ren Am­brose taught him al­geb­ra­ic to­po­logy and was a great in­flu­ence. He read Is­ad­ore Sing­er’s dif­fer­en­tial geo­metry notes and Ei­len­bergSteen­rod on al­geb­ra­ic to­po­logy, but Barry says that he was so ig­nor­ant and ri­dicu­lously opin­ion­ated that he held a strong pre­ju­dice against those sub­jects: al­geb­ra­ic and dif­fer­en­tial to­po­logy were “cheats,” he felt. Real to­po­logy was raw and pure; it did not need any ex­tra struc­ture.

After two years at MIT, Barry was es­sen­tially done, al­though he did not re­ceive a de­gree due to fail­ing the ROTC re­quire­ment. He entered Prin­ceton in fall 1956. Steen­rod ad­vised him, “Don’t read books, read pa­pers.” He sug­ges­ted that Barry think about 4-man­i­folds with a non-de­gen­er­ate Lorentz-type met­ric and play with them. But Barry’s real in­flu­ences in Prin­ceton were the oth­er gradu­ate stu­dents such as John Stallings, Han Sah, Ray Smul­ly­an, Her­man Gluck, Mar­vin Green­berg, Dick As­key, and oth­ers. They ran sem­inars to­geth­er tak­ing turns lec­tur­ing.

But there were no girls in Prin­ceton, so he de­cided to go to Par­is for 1957–58 to join up with his high-school girl­friend. In Par­is, he at­ten­ded the Cartan sem­in­ar and a course by Che­val­ley, which might have been something of a pre­curs­or to the scheme-the­or­et­ic view­point. Barry’s private goal, though, was — of all things — to prove the Poin­caré Con­jec­ture. Fairly soon, he thought up something that he viewed as a tiny shred of pro­gress, per­haps the first step to­wards a proof: a res­ult that he called “Lemma 1.” Of course, no proof of the Poin­caré Con­jec­ture ap­peared.

Upon re­turn­ing to Prin­ceton in spring 1958, Barry over­heard people in the Com­mon Room talk­ing about something called the Schoen­flies Con­jec­ture: a prob­lem about em­bed­ding codi­men­sion-one spheres in spheres. “But this is just my Lemma 1,” Barry thought. He blur­ted out the state­ment of that Lemma 1, and said that he could prove it. This was greeted with a very skep­tic­al look by Ral­ph Fox, who said that, if he could do that, Fox would get him a job at the In­sti­tute for Ad­vanced Study. Well, Barry could, and Fox did. So Barry spent 1958–59 as a fel­low at IAS, un­der Mar­ston Morse.

In the mean­time, Barry showed his proof to R H Bing ( who was a vis­it­or at the In­sti­tute of Ad­vanced Study that year). Bing im­me­di­ately un­der­stood it and was very help­ful. Barry lists Bing, along with Fox, as his PhD ad­visors.

After his year at IAS, Barry went to Har­vard, be­com­ing a Ju­ni­or Fel­low at Har­vard in 1959. He nev­er left Har­vard, be­com­ing even­tu­ally the Ger­hard Gade Uni­versity Pro­fess­or.